Homemade Green Enchilada Sauce Recipe (with Roasted Tomatillos)

The BEST homemade green enchilada sauce recipe that you’ve ever tried! Just follow my tips to make the most amazing green enchilada sauce, to take your chicken enchiladas to a whole new level.

A super easy, authentic green enchilada sauce that is made with oven roasted tomatillos. Plus, learn how to add even more flavor to this very simple recipe.

First published May 2016

This authentic Mexican green enchilada sauce is so much better than any store-bought enchilada sauce. I like to make mine extra spicy, but you can make it mild, or to your liking. The roasted tomatillos and peppers make the flavors of this sauce pop even more. It makes for the best chicken enchiladas!

Why I love this recipe

• Because I roast the tomatillos, the acidity is more muted, and the flavors of the tomatillos shine through.
• This is a recipe guide for green enchilada sauce, and I share how to add the most flavor to get the BEST green enchilada sauce made with tomatillos.
• This recipe is gluten free and vegan friendly as well.
• You can easily make it into a creamy enchilada sauce (although that’s not my personal preference).
• I also provide substitutions to make this recipe even easier to make.

The difference between red enchilada sauce and green enchilada sauce is in the ingredients. Red enchilada sauce is made with a variety of red chilis, whereas green enchilada is made with various types of green chili and tomatillo. Because of the green chili, the green sauce can be spicier than the red sauce, but my recipe is super easy to adapt to make it mild.

The balance of spicy, tangy and freshness is what makes the green enchilada tomatillo sauce my favorite recipe. Salsa verde and green enchilada sauce have similar tastes, because salsa verde is the backbone for tomatillo enchilada sauce recipes. So, if you like salsa verde, then you’ll absolutely love this recipe!

Ingredients

For the most flavorful version

Roasted tomatillos enchilada sauce uses the same ingredients as salsa verde as the base.

• Tomatillos – Mexican husk tomatoes
• Poblano peppers and jalapeno peppers
• Onion
• Garlic
• Cilantro
• Lime
• Cumin and salt

In addition to the salsa verde ingredients, you will also need,

• 1.5 cups stock (or leftover liquid from making carnitas)
• Cilantro roots or coriander seeds
• Orange juice
• Lime juice
• Cornstarch or flour

This will make a small batch of mojo flavored stock that will make your green sauce for enchiladas even more flavorful!

For the quick version

To shave off some time, there are shortcuts you can take. But I can guarantee the flavor won’t be as good as the recipe I’m sharing here with you!

You can purchase canned tomatillos, OR premade salsa verde.

And instead of making a mojo flavored stock, you can buy premade plain chicken or vegetable stock instead.

How to make green enchilada sauce with roasted tomatillos

Making the roasted salsa verde base

The first step is to prep all the vegetables and fruits (tomatillos) and place them on a lined baking tray. Preheat the oven to 450 F. Then roast them in a very hot oven (or broil) until they soften and get a nice char on them.

Once the tomatillos and peppers are charred, blend them in a food processor along with the cumin, cilantro, lime and salt. You can make it chunky or super smooth – that is entirely up to you.

Once the salsa verde is made, you’re ready to proceed with the green enchilada tomatillo sauce recipe.

Making the green sauce

While the tomatillos are roasting in the oven, you can make the mojo flavored stock by simmering stock with orange juice, lemon juice, and cilantro roots.

This stock is used to thin out the salsa verde to the consistency you prefer, and add more lime juice and salt to your taste.

Personally, I like to add a little more sauce, and then thicken it with some cornstarch or a roux.

For a quick green enchilada sauce

Making green enchilada sauce with salsa verde is the easiest and fastest method and it can be made with store-bought salsa verde of your choice. All you need to do is cook the store-bought salsa verde with store-bought stock to the right consistency. Then add some lime juice and salt to your taste.

You can also make the salsa verde from scratch, and use it to make enchilada sauce as well.

Variations and ingredient substitutions

To make a creamy green enchilada sauce – Add 1/4 cup sour cream to the sauce. You can also add vegan sour cream.

Gluten free green sauce – Use cornstarch instead of a flour roux.

Vegan version – Use vegetable stock and vegan sour cream (if using).

To make a milder version – Skip the jalapenos.

You can also substitute the poblano peppers with hatch chile for a green chile enchilada sauce!

Recipes that use roasted tomatillo sauce

Green enchiladas like green chicken enchiladas or green pork enchiladas.

Verde casseroles.

Green chilaquiles – while ususally made with salsa verde, can also be made with this tomatillo based enchilada sauce.

Use the green tomatillo enchilada sauce to make pulled pork or chicken too!

Storing the sauce for later

Place the sauce in an air-tight container or glass jar (with a tight fitting lid). Let it cool to room temperature, and store in the fridge for about 5 days.

You can also store it in the freezer for up to 3 months.