Classic Pound Cake – A complete guide on how to make perfect, and delicious Pound Cake! Tips + Tricks and Troubleshooting guide.
This is a comprehensive post with step by step instructions on how to make a Classic Pound Cake!
I’ll be sharing tips and techniques, pound cake troubleshooting ideas as well as cheat codes to help you make perfect, moist pound cakes. This classic pound cake is so easy and fool-proof, you can nail it even if you’re a baking novice!
This is a long post, so you can zip straight down to the recipe below if you like. But if you’re looking for tips and tricks to PERFECT your pound cake, then you’re in the right place!
So let’s start at the beginning.
Why is it called a pound cake?
Pound cakes first originated in Europe. They’ve been around since as early as the 1700s, and the term traditionally referred to a cake that weighed four pounds. That’s because a classic pound cake consisted of 1 pound of each of the following FOUR ingredients,
- Butter
- Sugar
- Eggs
- Flour
As you can notice, a classic pound cake doesn’t rely on any leavening agents to give the cake any lift, or any extra liquid to make the cake moist. The result is a dense cake, that was also somewhat dry (especially when over-baked).
As pound cakes have become more popular throughout history and throughout different parts of the world, different variations of the classic pound cake have emerged, that are lighter and more moist. Each region (or country) has their own version of a classic pound cake, incorporating different ratios of the main ingredients, and sometimes including extra liquid and baking powder too.
A moist pound cake recipe was the first cake that I learned to bake as well! 🙂 For this pound cake troubleshooting post, I baked all kinds of variations of a pound cake. You can see the results below, and I’ll help you troubleshoot some common pound cake mistakes as well!
Tips to follow for the BEST classic pound cake
Start with good ingredients
Well, that’s a given, but it’s especially true with pound cakes. Rather than using generic ingredients, try and use brand name ingredients.
Sugar
When it comes to sugar, make sure to get cane sugar because it has a finer grain than other white sugars (if it doesn’t say cane sugar, then it’s probably beet sugar). If you can get your hands on pure cane caster sugar (super fine sugar) that’s even better!
Butter
With butter, use a GOOD quality butter. Not margarine, not spreadable butter, but classic butter. I prefer to use unsalted butter, but you can use salted butter as well. However, due to the higher water content in salted butter, there’s a higher chance for inconsistent results when using salted butter as well.
Eggs
Use organic, free-range eggs whenever possible. However, avoid using really fresh eggs. Shocker right?
I prefer to use eggs that are about 1 week old and here’s why. The egg whites in fresh eggs are tighter and thicker whereas in older eggs, the egg whites are thinner and looser. These older eggs mix into the cake batter more easily and readily, resulting in a pound cake that’s lighter in mouthfeel and crumb texture. Another reason is that fresh eggs are heavier than older eggs – so 8 fresh large eggs would be way heavier than 1 lb, while 8 older large eggs would be closer to 1 lb.
Flour
I like to use unbleached all purpose flour. This is because it is more widely available.
But you can also use cake flour instead. This is lighter, and has less gluten than all purpose flour. Resulting in pound cake that rises a little more, and has a more tender crumb.
If you choose to go with pastry flour, you can substitute cake flour for AP flour at a 1:1 ratio – BY WEIGHT (not volume).
Always WEIGH your ingredients, rather than relying on cups.
I am a HUGE advocate of using an inexpensive kitchen scale for all your baking needs. Baking does need some precision and a cheap weighing scale will ensure consistent baking results every time, which will save you so much more time and money in the long run from failed recipes and wasted ingredients.
For example, when measuring flour with a cup, you can potentially get up to 50% more flour than you intended. OR, if you choose to use cake flour for your classic pound cake instead – 1 cup of cake flour is lighter than AP flour, so you will end up with LESS cake flour than needed for your recipe if you use a cup to measure.
When measuring sugar with a cup, 1 cup of regular sugar will weigh LESS than 1 cup of super fine sugar. So again, this is why a measuring scale would be really handy. Or you could easily end up with a sickly sweet pound cake because of too much sugar.
If you do use cups however…
It’s important to fluff up the flour and sugar in the container, and then scoop the flour and sugar into the measuring cup to the point of overflowing. Then, using a flat knife, level off the excess flour/sugar. It would still be difficult to guarantee consistent results this way, however.
If you’re living in the US, then 1 stick of butter = 4 oz / 115 g / or 0.5 cups. But for anywhere else in the world, the best thing would be to measure the butter as well using a measuring scale.
Temperature of ingredients
It’s absolutely important that all the ingredients are at room temperature (70-75°F or 20 – 23°C).
Butter
Butter should be softened, but not too softened. Here’s a crude way of checking if your butter is at the right consistency – make an indentation in the butter with your finger. If the butter is too hard to make an indentation, then well, the butter is too hard. 🙂 But if the butter does make an indentation, but it doesn’t keep its shape, and the butter around the indentation loses shape, then the butter is too soft (the butter can also be too oily when it’s this soft). If it’s easy to make an indentation but it also keeps its shape without distorting any of the butter in the surrounding area, then it’s at the correct consistency!
In the winter, I remove the butter from the fridge and keep it outside overnight. But in the summer, this could make the butter too soft. So instead, in the summer, I prefer to cut the butter into table spoon sized pieces and then leave them out to soften for about 30 minutes or so. If the butter gets too soft, then you can simply stick it back in the fridge for about 10-15 minutes to let them chill just a little bit.
Room temperature butter creams and whips easily. This is important because the butter will incorporate air during creaming/whipping which is essential for a light pound cake. If it’s too cold/hard, or too soft/melted, then it cannot hold air while being whipped.
Eggs
Eggs should also be kept outside overnight, so that they are all at room temperature. This will help the eggs retain air as well, while being mixed.
Flour and sugar should also be at room temperature. I usually store flour and sugar at room temperature anyway, but if you store flour in the fridge, remember to remove it from the fridge the night before.
How to make Pound cake – Step by step.
Since a classic pound cake does not rely on baking powder or baking soda for the cake to rise, the process of mixing the ingredients is crucial. That’s because this classic pound cake relies heavily on the air that is being incorporated during the mixing of butter and sugar, which further gets trapped by the gluten and eggs during baking.
There are only FOUR STEPS for a classic pound cake – butter, adding sugar, adding eggs, and adding flour. Each step is equally important. Make sure EACH INGREDIENT HAS BEEN WEIGHED and prepared (and sifted), BEFORE you start making the pound cake.
Stand mixer vs Hand mixer
I prefer to use a stand mixer over a hand mixer for convenience. You need to cream the butter and sugar together for a few minutes to incorporate the air, and trust me, your hands will thank you if you use a stand mixer instead of a hand mixer.
Creaming butter and sugar
The butter needs to be mixed for a few minutes (about 3 – 7 minutes, depending on the room temp. and the butter temp.) by itself first. Use the standard mixer attachment in your mixer to do this (not the whip or the dough hook), and this will ensure the incorporation of air in the butter, making it light, fluffy and creamy. Another mistake to avoid is running the stand mixer at high speed to speed up the process. DO NOT DO THIS! The high speed can knock the air out really fast. So run the mixer at medium speed to let the air in slowly but surely!
When the butter is fluffy, then the sugar is added. Make sure not to dump all the sugar in at once. The weight of the sugar can cause the butter to deflate, which is NOT good. So add the sugar in a thin, steady stream, while the stand mixer is running. This will help cream the butter and sugar together, evenly, adding more air, rather than knocking out the air.
The butter and sugar are creamed together for a few minutes as well. This is for two reasons – one, to incorporate more air and two, to dissolve the sugar. This is why I prefer to use caster sugar which dissolves much faster. The sugar may not need to be completely dissolved before the addition of the eggs, but they definitely should be completely dissolved after you add the eggs. If you’re using regular cane sugar, you can whiz the sugar separately in a food processor for a few seconds to make it finer, if you like.
Adding eggs
The next important step is the addition of eggs. The same principle as earlier of not weighing down the batter by adding all the eggs in at once, applies here too. There are TWO ways to achieve this,
- Lightly whisk all the eggs in a jug, and then add the eggs slowly in a stream, with a few breaks in between.
- Add the eggs one at a time, mixing each one well before adding the next.
Both techniques work, but for convenience, I usually go with the second method. I always crack an egg into a small bowl first, and add it while the stand mixer is running. I mix in the eggs for about 20 – 30 seconds, until the yolk has disappeared, and then I add the next egg.
It’s important to not let the eggs over-beat in the batter as well. If you over-beat the eggs, the cake WILL COLLAPSE AFTER BAKING!
Some recipes call for more egg yolks, instead of using whole eggs only. YOU CAN SUBSTITUTE TWO WHOLE EGGS, with FOUR YOLKS IF YOU PREFER. This will result in a cake that is richer in taste and more moist. The cake will have a richer yellow color as well.
But remember that egg whites add lift to the cake, while egg yolks add richness. The reason why some prefer to add egg yolks is because egg whites, while adding volume and lift to the cake, can also dry out the cake.
CHEAT NOTE 1 – Instead of two of the whole eggs in the recipe, add four egg yolks to get a more moist and richer tasting pound cake.
CHEAT NOTE 2 – I would also add 1 tsp of baking powder IF I substitute 2 eggs with FOUR EGG YOLKS. This is to compensate for the lack of egg whites.
Incorporating flour
Make sure the flour is sifted before you add it to the cake. It’s even better if you can sift it AGAIN when you’re adding it to the cake, but that’s not necessary. This is to reduce the likelihood of flour lumps forming when mixing the flour.
If you’re able to incorporate the flour with a baking spatula – DO IT! Folding in the flour by hand (spoon), will make sure that you don’t overwork the gluten in the flour.
If you do use your stand mixer, use the lowest speed on the stand mixer, and use it for the smallest amount of time.
If the gluten is over-worked, you will end up with a tougher and dense pound cake, NOT good. Another way to avoid this is to use cake flour instead of AP flour.
CHEAT NOTE – CAKE FLOUR can be substituted for AP flour because it’ll give a lighter texture to your pound cake. This will make your cake rise more in the oven too.
CHEAT NOTE – If you’re worried that your cake wasn’t beaten enough, you CAN add just the smallest amount of baking powder to make sure your pound cake rises properly. I ONLY do this if I use a hand mixer to mix my pound cake batter, because I know that then there’s a chance that I may not have incorporated enough air.
Baking the Cake
ACCURATE OVEN TEMPERATURE is important. It’ll be great if you know that your oven is properly calibrated. You can do this by placing an oven temp. reader in your oven, and then comparing the temp. displayed on your oven with that of the reader. If by chance your oven is not calibrated, you can adjust the baking temp. based on how your pound cake turns out on the first attempt.
If the cake is too dry, then the oven is too hot, and you may need to lower the temp. OR remove the cake from the oven earlier. If the cake is not done by 70 minutes, then the oven temp. needs to be increased, or the cake needs to bake longer.
Also make sure to PREHEAT THE OVEN for a good 10 – 15 minutes before putting your cake in. This way a stable oven temp. is guaranteed.
Your baking pans can have an effect on the baking times as well. If you use glass cake pans or dark metal pans, the baking time will shorten. If you’re using a light baking pan, then this recipe will be accurate, because I used a light baking pan as well.
I used two 8.5 x 4.5 inch loaf pans for this classic pound cake recipe. You can adapt this to make the cake in two 9.5 x 5.5 inch loaf pans, but be mindful to check on the cake earlier, as it will bake faster.
The final result is an incredibly buttery, soft, classic pound cake! The crumb is tight and together, but not dense or gummy – it’s buttery and soft and just so addictively delicious!
Classic Pound Cake serving ideas
You can enjoy this classic pound cake in SO MANY different ways! Serve it as is, or top it with various additions to make simple but delicious desserts. Check out these creative ways to serve this classic moist pound cake.
- Berries and cream (raspberries, strawberries, blueberries or any other type of berry)
- Banana and butterscotch sauce – this would taste like bananas foster, but with cake!
- Chocolate sauce or hazelnut chocolate spread! Who doesn’t love cake and chocolate (or Nutella) together?
- Whipped cream and nuts or praline – to enhance the nutty flavor even more, you can flavor your cake with nut flavoring as well (almond, toasted coconut, pistachios, or peanuts)
- Lemon glaze or lemon curd – a refreshing and tangy twist to your buttery pound cake! Either cover the cake with lemon glaze or pour it over cake slices. Alternatively, you can serve it with lemon curd or any kind of citrus curd.
- Whipped cream and Kahlua – THIS IS MY FAVORITE! It tastes like tiramisu! A shot of kahlua (or any other sweet liqueur that you like) poured over a cake slice, and then topped with whipped cream or ice cream. An irresistible option for the adults!
Other options not pictured here,
- Grill the pound cake slices (especially if you have stale pound cake), and serve them warm with grilled fruits and ice cream.
- Cut the cake into cubes and add them in trifles!
- Cut into cubes, then lightly toast them, and add them into fruit salads – they’ll be like dessert croutons!
- Make ice cream sandwiches with the pound cake.
Making a classic pound cake is a rewarding experience! 🙂 I hope this lengthy post helped you understand how a classic moist pound cake comes together and why each step is important. It’ll help you master the art of making classic pound cakes and then add your own personal touch to make the recipe even more versatile!
Back to Top
Pound cake comparisons
Pound cake troubleshooting
Chances are not enough air was incorporated into the butter and sugar. This could be because the creaming time wasn’t long enough, or because the sugar, eggs or flour were incorporated too quickly.
Solution – cream the butter until fluffy, and then incorporate the sugar in a thin stream. Add the eggs one by one, or in a stream. Add the flour in batches.
The gluten in the flour was overworked, causing the gluten to make the cake too heavy and too dense. Use minimal force to incorporate the flour.
Solution – Preferably, fold in the flour in batches using a spatula, or use the absolute shortest time with your stand mixer to mix in the flour on the lowest speed.
Make sure the flour is fully incorporated too – because dry flour streaks can result in a gummy pound cake.
Use cake flour instead of AP flour.
Pound cake is SUPPOSED to be a little dense. But it’s not supposed to feel heavy or dry. If it’s dry, the cake may have been over-baked. The cake can also be too dry if you added too much flour (or not enough butter or sugar).
Solution –
You can try lowering the oven temperature.
Or remove the cake from the oven a little earlier.
Or follow the recipe exactly – and refrain from adding extra flour or reducing the amount of sugar or butter.
This usually happens because the oven temperature is too high. Then the crust cooks a lot faster than the inside of the cake, creating a tough crust and a soft middle.
Solution –
Lower the temperature of the oven and cook the pound cake for longer.
Using a light colored loaf pan instead of a dark loaf pan also helps.
The butter and sugar were creamed too fast and too much! The cake rises, and then collapses while cooling, causing the cake to have dense, gummy (or gluey) spots.
Solution –
DON’T increase the speed of your mixer beyond medium speed. And lower the speed to the lowest setting when adding in the flour (or fold in the flour by hand).
If you over-beat the eggs, the air in the eggs will cause the cake to rise. It will create a crust that will rise higher than the cake (the same way that eggs can create a crust in brownies, they can create a crust in cakes as well). However, since the rest of the cake did not rise as much (since there is no baking powder etc), the crust will fall as the cake cools down, creating a wrinkled cake crust.
Solution –
Make sure to only beat the eggs to the point of incorporating the eggs. If you beat each egg for more than a minute each time, you may run into this issue.
These are sugar crystals. As the cake is baking, the unmelted sugar crystals melt with the heat of the oven, causing little spots to appear on the cake crust.
Solution –
Use cane sugar that’s a little finer than granulated white sugar.
Caster sugar is even better (super fine sugar – NOT confectioner’s sugar)
If you can’t find caster sugar, you can process the sugar for a few seconds (a few pulses) in your food processor to turn them super fine. If you’re using measuring cups, make sure to WEIGH THE SUGAR FIRST before putting it through the food processor (super fine sugar measures differently than granulated sugar when using cups)
This classic pound cake should not sink in the middle, unless the cake was under-baked or extra liquid was added.
Solution –
If you’re using salted butter, try the cake with unsalted butter, and eliminate all other extra liquids (if you added milk for example)
Bake the cake for longer.
If you over-beat the eggs, or beat the butter and sugar too fast, or added too much baking powder, the cake can rise too much and flow over the edges of the pan.
Solution –
Reduce the mixing time and don’t use high speed to mix the ingredients.
If you prefer to use baking powder, consider using a 9 x 5 inch loaf pan, instead of a 8 x 4 inch loaf pan.
If you liked this recipe, you may also like,
Fudgy One Bowl Chocolate Sheet Cake
Super Easy Chocolate Molten Cakes
Looking for more recipes?Sign up for my free recipe newsletter to get new recipes in your inbox each week! Find me sharing more inspiration on Pinterest and Instagram.
Classic Pound Cake
Ingredients:
- 1 lb unsalted butter softened at room temperature (4 sticks of butter)
- ½ tsp fine sea salt
- 1 lb cane sugar or caster sugar (about 2 ¼ cups)
- 8 large eggs 1 lb of eggs, with shell on
- 14 oz AP flour or cake flour roughly 3 ¼ cups AP flour
- 1 tsp baking powder (optional)
- 2 tsp good quality vanilla extract you can add almond extract, or any other flavor extract you prefer
Instructions:
- Butter two 8.5 x 4.5 inch loaf pans, and dust the inside of the pans with flour to coat. Shake off excess flour. Set aside.
- Preheat oven to 325°F/170°C.
- Weigh out all the ingredients and keep them close at hand. Sift the flour and set aside in a bowl.
- Optional step – if you’re using granulated cane sugar, place the sugar in a food processor and pulse a few times to get a finer sugar texture.
- Remove the mixing bowl from the weighing scale and place it in your stand mixer with the beater attachment attached.
- Place the softened butter and salt in the bowl and cream the butter until light, creamy and fluffy (between 3 – 7 minutes), at medium speed (speed 4 – 5 on a kitchen aid mixer). Scrape the sides and bottom of the bowl to make sure you collect all of the butter.
- Add the sugar in a thin, steady stream WHILE the butter is being mixed (you can also add the sugar tablespoon at a time as well). It should take approximately 1 min to incorporate the sugar into the butter. Stop the mixer and scrape the sides and bottom of the bowl to ensure that the sugar is evenly mixed.
- Cream the butter and sugar for a further 2 – 3 minutes.
- Break an egg into a small bowl, and make sure there are no egg shells. Break the egg yolk, and then pour the egg in a stream into the butter-sugar mix. Mix for about 20 – 30 seconds until the egg has incorporated into the batter, and there are no traces of egg yolk. Repeat with another egg. After 2 eggs have been mixed into the batter, stop the mixer and scrape the sides and the bottom of the bowl.
- Repeat with the rest of the eggs, making sure to scrape the sides and bottom as you go (I do this after every 2 eggs that I add).
- When all the eggs have been added, add the vanilla and mix for a further 30 sec – 1 minute.
Mixing in the flour by hand – You will need a long-handled baking spatula to fold the flour into the batter
- Stop the mixer and remove the mixing bowl from the stand mixer. Sift about ¼ of the flour over the batter. Fold the flour into the batter, while rotating the bowl after each fold, until the flour is just incorporated. Repeat 3 more times with the remaining flour, so that you carefully incorporate all of the flour while folding it into the batter (rather than vigorous mixing). This will give you a smooth cake batter.
- Make sure there are no dry bits of flour in your batter.
Mixing in the flour with a stand mixer
- Reduce the speed of the stand mixer to the lowest setting (stir speed in a kitchen aid mixer).
- Add ¼ of the sifted flour into the batter, and mix for a few seconds until just incorporated. Repeat with 3 more additions. After the final addition, only mix the batter until you have a smooth batter. Stop immediately.
Baking the pound cakes
- Add an equal amount of the batter to the bottom of each loaf pan. Using an offset spatula, spread the batter evenly to the corners of the pan. Add the rest of the batter (equally divided between the two loaf pans) to the two loaf pans. Evenly spread on top to have an even surface. Gently shake the pans (just a little) to make sure the batter is evenly spread (don’t knock the cake pans on the counter!).
- Transfer the loaf pans into the oven (ideally in the lower third of the oven, and right in the center of the oven rack). Set the timer for 40 minutes. After 40 minutes, rotate the cake pans, and bake for a further 20 minutes.
- Check the cake after a total of 60 minutes of bake time to test the done-ness of the cake with a clean toothpick or a cake tester. Insert the cake tester into the cake, and if it comes out clean, then the cake is done. In my oven, these cakes take about 67 – 70 minutes to bake.
- Remove the cakes from the oven, and allow them to cool down for about 10 – 15 minutes. Carefully turn thee cakes out onto a cooling wire rack to cool down completely.
- Eat warm, or at room temperature.
How to store Pound Cake
- When the cake is at room temperature, it can be wrapped well with plastic wrap, and stored in an airtight container, and be consumed within a week. If the cake isn’t wrapped properly, it can become stale, BUT stale pound cake will taste even better when toasted or grilled.
- OR you can wrap the cake in plastic wrap, and foil, and then stored in the freezer for up to 3 months.
Tips & Tricks
- Right at the start, BEFORE adding butter into the mixing bowl – place the empty mixing bowl on a weighing scale and note the weight of the bowl (this is optional, but helps to evenly distribute the cake batter between the pans later).
- When the cake batter is made, scrape any batter off of the spatula and remove the spatula from the bowl. Then measure the weight of the bowl + batter, and subtract the weight of the bowl from the value. This is the weight of the batter. Divide this value by two, and this will be how much you should add to each loaf pan (this further helps get PERFECT, evenly baked pound cakes).
- If you’re using two 9.5 inch x 5.5 inch pans, check on the cakes after 45 – 50 minutes. This is because this cake can cook much faster in these bigger pans.
- Bundt cake pan – this recipe is enough for 1 large bundt cake. Keep an eye on the cake after 50 minutes of baking time.
Nutrition Information:
“This website provides approximate nutrition information for convenience and as a courtesy only. Nutrition data is gathered primarily from the USDA Food Composition Database, whenever available, or otherwise other online calculators.”
If you love cake, then you will absolutely love my new cookbook Secret Layer Cakes!
If you don’t have a copy, then you really really should get one NOW! 🙂 That is, if you like combining a fantastic array of delicious flavors and textures and different types of dessert into outrageously inventive cakes (that’s where the idea of secret layers comes from!), that are also surprisingly easy. There are 60 recipes in the book for cheesecakes, no bake cakes, ice cream cakes and all types of dessert mash ups, like this Fudgy S’mores Brownie Pie here.
Claudia says
Love it
Catrin says
Hi Dini – I loved your blog! It was so interesting – I felt like I went to Pound Cake U-lol…thank you for sharig this excellent knowledge for all of us to become better at our craft! I am now going to make your cake! Thanks again for sharing…You definitely “take the Cake’ (in a good way!)
BTW – I was looking for a good Peach Pond Cake Recipe and maybe other fruits like raspberry, strawberry – do I need to change anything in this base and how much and when would you add the fruit and maybe different flavorings? Thank you.
Michelle says
Thanks for sharing this info because I certainly need it. My pound cake which I baked yesterday needs help. It has dense wet looking areas in it. The texture is not ideal but the taste is good. Pound cakes have been a challenge for me;while I have finally gotten the technique down for layer cakes, I’m ready to get the pound cake perfected. Thanks for your expertise. I will definitely be applying to my next pound cake venture
Paula foya says
This helped me a lot
Kelli says
What icing would yu use for this?
Dini says
Hi Kelli
I typically don’t use frosting for pound cake, but a glaze would be more common on pound cake.
Any easy, quick glaze would be a mixture of milk and confectioners glaze with a little vanilla (whisked until you have a thick but pourable consistency). You can also make a fondant glaze, that’s made with white sugar cooked with water and corn syrup, but I prefer the quicker version.
Beverly says
In your recipe for pound cake it calls for 8 eggs. In the cheat section it says add 4 egg yolks for two eggs. Am I still adding a total of 8 ?
Dini says
Hi Beverly!
The note says “Instead of two of the eggs in the recipe, add four egg yolks to get a more moist and richer tasting pound cake.” Which means, that 2 of the eggs can be replaced with 4 egg yolks. So you will be adding 4 egg yolks + 6 eggs if you want a richer, egg yolk heavy pound cake.
Hope that helps!
Dee says
So, 10 eggs instead of 8?
Dini says
Hi Dee
The recipe uses 8 whole eggs.
As stated in the recipe, if you want a richer cake you will be using 4 egg yolks plus 6 eggs (instead of 8 whole eggs). So yes, you will technically need 10 eggs, but only the yolks from 4 eggs for that richer version of the recipe.
Hope that helps
flubna says
Wow! Looks so good. Want to ask something, i’m using a small oven with only 3 rack level, lower, middle and top. Should i bake it at the lower level or middle? Hoping for you to answer. Can’t wait to bake!!!
Dini says
Hi Flubna
I have a conventional oven and I bake the cake in the middle rack because it’s the spot where the cake will bake the most evenly.
For most ovens, the middle rack is sufficient. But if your oven is hotter from the bottom or top, you may need to adjust it.
I hope that helps!
Jolene Ton says
Wow, I loved this post, full of info to help me get this cake right, thank you!!
Maj says
I filled the recipe. The cake was heavy and oily. So disappointing and waste of ingredients.
There was oil bubbling at the top of the loaf after baking
Dini says
Hi Maj
I’m sorry to hear it didn’t work for you! It sounds like either the flour was not measured correctly (too little flour), or the batter wasn’t emulsified properly, causing the butter to break and separate while baking. This cake is meant to be dense because it’s a pound cake after all (as described in the post).
I’ve made this recipe 100s of times since I was 8 years old, so it’s a very well tested recipe, and I’ve never had this happen to me. So I’d love to help you figure out what went wrong!
MELODY ANTONIO says
What a wonderful post!
The instructions and troubleshooting hints are so through!
I usually have to read several posts to get this much information!
Your post teaches not only the beginner, but even an advanced baker can benefit from it.
Thank you so much!
A D Johnson says
You are the diamond in the crown of the princess baking crown you should be wearing! I tried this but I added heavy whipping cream and used egg yolks and one egg they were farm fresh…and your notes saved me so much time. I also used baby cake loaf pans. They taste delicious. Thank you!
Dana says
Hi there, can this be turned into a marble pound cake so with the chocolate and vanilla. I love this pound cake so much so wondering how the cocoa powder can be incorporated to create a dense marble pound cake
Brenda Lawrence says
Hi Dini:
Thank you for the detailed explanation, however, my pound cake didn’t turn out, too much butter and I can see the oil bubbling in the oven and set off the smoke alarm. I followed each step and used the exact ingredients. Don’t know what happened here.
Dini says
Hi Brenda
It sounds like the batter didn’t emulsify properly and the butter separated from the batter.
Did the batter look curdled when you divided it into the pans?
Melanie says
Hi Dini, I have been asked to make a birthday pound cake. I’m thinking to make a 3 layer cake. What pan size, and timing would you recommend?
Also what frosting or glaze would go well with this? I am hoping for something not too overpowering so that the flavour of the cake can be the star of the show, but still look pretty enough as a bday cake. Thanks!
Dini says
Hi Melanie
That’s a tricky question…
A traditional pound cake (like this recipe), is a pretty dense cake. So if you bake it in a larger cake pan, you run the risk of having very dry edges, or an under-cooked center. Which is why most traditional pound cake recipes are made either in the shape shown in this post, or in bundt cake pans that allow for even heat distribution in the center of the cake. You could maybe bake cake layers in a 6 inch round cake pan because it’s smaller in size (and you could possibly bake about 4 layers with this recipe – baked at the same temperature, but only baked long enough that a toothpick comes out clean).
The round pound cake recipes that I’ve found online aren’t true pound cake recipes either, because they don’t have the classic pound cake ratios of ingredients. This is because you need a lighter cake batter that will bake more evenly in a cake pan. They are simply variations of a vanilla cake.
If you do decide to try to bake a layered pound cake, you could use this classic American vanilla buttercream that is not overwhelmingly sweet and will be sturdy enough to be a filling between two layers of pound cake. You could also go with swiss meringue buttercream. If you wanted to, whipped cream would be perfect for the outside of this cake, but I’m afraid it won’t be sturdy enough to use as a filling between cake layers.
I hope that helps!
Melanie says
Hi Dini, thanks for your advice, they are really helpful. I have decided to do this in a bundt pan. Just ordered one, and can’t wait to make it!
Subhashini Sekar says
My cake is perfectly baked except that the sides, top and bottom doesn’t not have a brown crust!! Its all pale off-white!!! What could have gone wrong?? This happens especially for pound cakes.. any remedies???
Dini says
Hi Subhashini
The cake browning can change depending on the oven you use, or the baking pan you use and the recipe you use.
Pound cake has less sugar than other cakes. This can lead to the cake not readily browning as other high ratio (high sugar) cakes. Coupled with the oven you have can lead to a pound cake not browning properly. What kind of oven do you use? Using a glass baking pan can also prevent a crust from forming.
I hope that helps
Gina says
Hi! I made a pound cake that used sour cream and butter milk in a fluted bundt pan. My cake was done, very moist, melt in your mouth moist but did not form a crust or truly brown. I was afraid of overcooking so I took it out. Do you know what I possibly did wrong as to why it didn’t brown or form a crust? I did alternated wet and dry mixtures but finished with wet.
Dini says
Hi Gina
I can’t really give you a proper answer as I don’t know the recipe that you used. However in my experience a cake doesn’t brown if it wasn’t baked long enough, or in an oven that’s not hot enough (or the lower filament in the oven isn’t working properly). It can also happen if the cake was baked in a glass or ceramic baking dish too.
I hope that helps
Carol williams says
I made this but added 1 1/2c mini choc chips and put in 9* &5 bread stoneware pan. Middle was not done for longer than stated but now it seems very dry. Still delicious but I expected more moist cake. 350 but over 60 min to have clean toothpick!
Dini says
Hi Carol
I avoid baking cake in stoneware pans because I find that it doesn’t bake the cake they way I want it to. The way it heats up and distributes/retains heat can have an impact on the cake. With glass/stoneware pans I do prefer to reduce the heat of the oven and it will take a longer time to bake because it is slower to heat up. It ends up cooking the outside of the cake too fast, and reaches the center too slow. As a result you will end up with a cake that is drier.
You can read this article for more information if you like.
Nina says
I love the detailed description for the recipe. I used another’s pound cake recipe lets just say it was a brick. What can I do if I want to half this recipe to make one pan instead of two?
Dini says
Hi Nina!
Absolutely!! Just make sure that you cream the butter properly. The reason why I make two cakes at a time is because my stand mixer does a better job of creaming butter than my hand held mixer. If I use my hand held mixer to make the batter, then I also add baking powder to make sure my cake isn’t too dense.
Emma Fair says
I love baking cakes, this information helped a lot.
Morgan says
Hi Dini! I tried this recipe a few weeks ago and the cake was absolutely divine! I’m making the cake again, but want to add buttermilk or sour cream to the mixture. Should I add the buttermilk or sour cream before or after incorporating the flour?
Dini says
Hi Morgan!
Any liquids must be added before adding the flour. You can alternate adding the liquid and flour, as long as you finish with the flour addition. Depending how much you add, liquids will change the texture of the cake as well and you may need to adjust other ingredients to maintain the same dense pound cake like texture. It will also be important to add the baking powder to the flour mixture as well. The excess moisture may collapse the cake or not rise at all.
I hope that helps
Sue Smith says
Looks wonderful.
Can you halve the recipe, only want one cake.
Dini says
Hi Sue!
Yes you can 🙂
Brittany says
Excellent recipe! I did a riff on this, since I’m in Australia and we don’t measure things in pounds (so technically it’s a half-kilo cake :P), and I did 500 grams each of salted butter, caster sugar, eggs and plain flour, and added in 1 tsp baking powder and 2 tsp vanilla essence.
I also folded in 1.2 kilos of stewed spiced apple puree at the very end and put it into my largest pyrex dish to bake at 170C for 80 minutes. It came out so beautifully; light and fluffy, with the spiced apple marbled through it, and a lovely golden-brown top.
Very grateful for the tips and explanations about pound cake, it was very useful!
Elsa Collins says
I read the recipe an I am excited to try it.I see all the mistakes I have been making. Thank you for your research.
T. Gayle says
Please help!!! When I take my cake out of the oven, the top crack really bad. When I take the cake out of the pan, the crust crack, causing some of the outside of the cake to come off.
Dini says
Hi T.Gayle
Would you be able to send me some pictures to theflavorbender (at) gmail (dot) com? It’s hard for me to visualize what you are describing. If I have more details or a picture I might be able to help more!
Morgan says
Can I bake this in a pan as a slice at about 1 inch thick or would it be to dry as it is a lot thinner? I would like to try and use it for a petit four recipe. Also what amount of time and temperature would you recommend?
Dini says
Hi Morgan
You can, but I haven’t done it myself to know which pan you should use.
I recommend starting with maybe a 8 x 8 inch pan and pouring cake batter about 3/4 – 1 inch high inside the cake pan and bake until done (you can always trim off the excess). The cake is done when a toothpick comes out clean. The time will be greatly reduced because the cake is much thinner. It can also vary depending on the thickness, and the size of the pan you use, so it can take anywhere between 15 – 40 minutes at 350°F.
Hope that helps!
Morgan says
Thank you! I have the perfect pan, I can’t wait to try it!
Cass says
Very useful, what if you use cream cheese, beat first or with butter
Dini says
Hi Cass
You could sub some of the butter with cream cheese, but it will make the cake more dense because of the cream cheese. I recommend adding baking powder to make it lighter. I would beat the cream cheese lightly first, so that it will blend more smoothly and cream better with the butter.
Hope that helps!
Debbie says
Thank you so much for your detailed commentary. Now I know why my pound cake collapses in top. I am ready to try again and not over beat my eggs!
Mary Lou Gross says
I loved this cake but had baking probems- I used a rectangular pan, shiny silver on the outside and dark non-stick surface on the inside. I baked the cake st 325* for 1 hr 15 minutes. It was crispy on the edges and raw in the middle. Oven thermometer seems to be working fine. So…do I consider this a dark pan or a light colored pan? Could this be the problem??? Help!!!
Dini says
Hi Mary!
I’m sorry you had baking problems. Darker pans do get hot faster, and retain heat longer. For that reason they can create a caramelized edge before the heat reaches the middle of the pan.
Since pound cake is a really thick and tall cake (compared to a layer cake), it does need to bake evenly and slowly. I would recommend using a light colored pan next time, so that the cake can bake more evenly. I use an Aluminized Steel Loaf Pan. OR you can use the same pan, but you will need to reduce the baking temperature by about 25 degrees at least. I hope that helps and you can get a more perfect cake next time 🙂
Dora Moses says
I love it, very moist and light pound cake. Can I use and 10 inchpound cake pan
Dora Moses says
One of the best homemade pound cake i made,question.is it better to weigh your ingredients than to measures bc I never weighed my ingredients. But, i did in this recipe
Cecilia Y-Kosol says
I’m so glad I happened to find your recipe and tips. That means there is hope I’ll be making baking a moist and tasty pound cake for the first time. I’ll go back and read again to make sure I thoroughly follow every single detail of cake preparation, will let you know how it turns out.
Cecilia
Krista Aldridge says
This recipe calls for 14 oz of flour which you state is roughly 3 and 1/2 cups but to my understanding it’s about 2 and 3/4 cups
Dini says
Hi Krista
The recipe states 3 1/4 cups for 14 oz. The reason is because I use a spoon and level method, where 1 cup of flour is between 4.2 – 4.4 oz. If you use the scoop and level method then the flour will weigh more per each cup. I find that weighing the ingredients will be the most accurate way of measuring ingredients so that there is minimal variation. You can read more here. I hope that helps!
Zaria says
Hello! I’m really interested in trying out your recipe and it looks delicious but I would like to add blueberries. Do I have to make any altercations to the recipe listed above?
Taylor's Mom says
My cakes were wonderful! I can’t believe how light and airy the cakes were. My loaf pans are a bit darker than my other cake pans so I reduced the temperature to 300 degrees. My only error was leaving them in the pan too long. They shrank quite a bit. I’m thinking that with the dark pans the carryover cooking was too much. I won’t make that mistake again. I froze the second cake but it’s already out thawing. We made strawberry shortcake and it was the best I ever tasted. This recipe is definitely a keeper! Thanks again for sharing!
Taylor's Mom says
I can’t wait to try this recipe. I’m waiting patiently for my ingredients to come yo room temperature. Your comparisons are amazing and very helpful! I’m going to try it with APbflour then cake flour jext. I can’t wait to report back on my results! Thanks so much for sharing! It’s clear that you put a lot of work into perfecting your recipe.
Jackie says
Hi! Can this recipe be turned into lemon pound cake?
Dini says
Hi Jackie!
I do like to add lots of lemon zest to my pound cakes which give it a lovely lemony flavor! I add about 1 tbsp of zested lemon per cake (so 2 tbsps for this recipe). You can drizzle some lemon syrup or lemon icing on top as well.
If you want to add lemon juice, you can add about 1/4 cup of strained lemon juice. You will have to add the 1 tsp baking powder to the recipe so that the cake won’t be too dense. I personally prefer just to add the lemon zest and not the juice.
Hope that helps!
Jackie says
Thank you! It turned out so light and tasty I only added the lemon zest and drenched it with sugar syrup and a lemon glaze! Your instructions are so clear it was foolproof! Thanks again!!!
Dini says
Hi Jackie!
You’re very welcome! I’m so glad it came out well!
Now my husband and I are craving some lemon pound cake too 😀 Might have to make some soon!
Amber Lowe says
Great advice – and excellent level of detail. Thank you
Dwight Lee says
I wondered how to remove the egg-like-smell whenever I made a kind of bread with eggs.
Following this way, I succeeded to eliminate the smell i don’t want to taste.
I am not sure it was because of the order of pouring the ingredients or dissolving eggs completely .. but.. I did ..Thanks so much for your recipe.
It was so hard to follow since you have too much things to be careful. but it worked..
Doing with so much care is the most needed one to make.
Great job!!!
Julio Roque Carreira says
Are you using 1000 gr of butter? Double the weight of eggs?
Thanks
Julio Carreira
Dini says
Hi Julio
I am using 450 grams of butter. You can find the metric weights of the ingredients by cliciking on the metric / US customary toggle buttons at the bottom of the ingredient list. The 8 large eggs will weight about 450 grams as well (with the shell).
Hope that makes sense!
Cheers,
Dini
Teresa Rowan says
Hi Dini , I would really like to make this recipe in 5.5″ x 3″ mini loaf pans and I am wondering about how much to reduce the time in the oven . I was thinking maybe 45 minutes @ 325 . Your tips are wonderful .
Kat says
What if I want to add cream cheese? When do I add the cream cheese to the recipe?
Nicole says
Hi Dini, thank you so much for this informative post! I’m a little confused, do we add the sugar while creaming the butter for 3-7 minutes or after this process?
Dini says
Hi Nicole
You have to cream the butter first, and then add the sugar in a thin stream after the initial 3 – 7 minutes. Please let me know if you have any other questions!
Sharon says
Love the cake making tips!
V says
Hello. Do I need to add baking powder to the recipe as given above?
Dini says
Hi V
I don’t add baking powder to the pound cake unless I feel that I wasn’t able to incorporate enough air into the cake batter. If I feel like I need to add it, then I would only add 1/2 tsp of baking powder.
Liz says
I’ve been making my grandmother’s pound cake recipe for years, and it’s always dense and heavy. Your recipe helped me to make, hands down, the BEST pound cake I’ve ever made! It’s airy, full of flavor, and delicious! Thank you!!!!!
Dini says
Yaay, so glad you liked the recipe Liz 🙂 Thank you so much for letting me know!
Erna says
Thankyou for the tips.! Love your way of teaching..
Dini says
Thank you Erna. 🙂 I hope the tips prove helpful to you!
Marjory says
Bookmark this one! It’s so nice to have everything you need in one place. Measure the ingredients by weight! So helpful!
Wilhelmina Wessel says
This is a great informative post!