Here’s all you need to know about making Perfect Classic Chocolate Eclairs! This foolproof tutorial will guide you through the recipe step by step, and also discuss eclairs troubleshooting tips for common recipe pitfalls.
Deliciously crisp, puffy and perfect chocolate eclairs filled with chocolate or vanilla pastry cream.
Have you been left wondering why your eclairs always came out flat or soggy? Or why they have a concave-shaped bottom, or a huge crack right down the middle on the bottom?
You’ve probably tried all the recipes that claim to make perfect eclairs, and still ended up with flat, depressing eclairs instead? Well, then you’ve come to the right place! 🙂
Today, I’m going to show you guys how to make Foolproof, Perfect Classic Eclairs!
My classic choux pastry troubleshooting post is one of the most popular posts on my blog, and I’ve had many readers ask me for a follow up post dedicated to classic eclairs. It’s been a long time coming, but here it is! However, I do encourage you to read my choux pastry troubleshooting recipe post first for a detailed and comprehensive guide on how to make perfect choux pastry and how to fix any shortcomings with the dough. It’ll help you troubleshoot common issues that you may encounter when making eclairs or any choux pastry dessert.
Here’s a quick summary.
The consistency of your choux pastry dough is key! Always WEIGH your ingredients, rather than relying on cup/volume measurements for guaranteed, consistent results. If you do use cups however, pay extra attention to the consistency of the dough at each step to make sure you’re on the right track.
There are key signs to look for at each step of making choux pastry, before you proceed to the next step. The more you make choux pastry, the more you will be able to “read” your dough and follow these signs intuitively.
If you’re new to making choux pastry, then how about starting with profiteroles first? Profiteroles are easier and more forgiving than classic eclairs, and I’ve got an excellent recipe for making profiteroles.
Having said that, I’m going to share with you here all my tips on making PERFECT eclairs that are nice and puffy, with a beautiful shell and with no cracks. This will help you make foolproof classic eclairs that look like they came from a high-end pastry shop! 🙂 So let’s get to it.
I’ll start with some common eclair fails that you’d potentially encounter when making classic eclairs.
My eclairs are flat and soggy.
This happens if your choux pastry dough is too runny (with too much water, eggs, or both).
Or you opened the oven too early while baking, causing steam to escape, which makes the eclair shells collapse.
Or you didn’t bake them long enough.
SOLUTION
- Keep an eye on the dough, and make sure you don’t add too many eggs.
- Never open the oven door before the 25 minute mark, to avoid letting out steam from the oven.
- Prick or cut the shell towards the end of the baking time (or soon after they are baked) to let steam escape as the pastry cools down.
- Never add raw flour to your choux pastry to “fix” runny dough. See the post here to find out how to fix runny choux pastry dough.
My eclairs have a sunken bottom, and sometimes there’s a large crack on the bottom as well.
This happens due to a combination of the reasons stated above. But in addition, your chocolate eclairs can also sink in at the bottom, if the pastry case isn’t sturdy enough to hold its shape.
This is not so much of an issue with profiteroles. This is because the shape of a profiterole is inherently sturdier than that of eclairs.
For profiteroles, the contact point of the pastry with the baking sheet is wider, so it has a more stable base to bake on and rise to form a nice, airy pastry shell. There’s less risk of collapsed pastry shells here.
For eclairs, the contact point with the baking sheet is less (in terms of the width of the pastry shell). So as they pastry shell expands when baking, it becomes less stable/sturdy and tends to collapse around the base, causing your eclair shells to have a concave-shaped collapsed bottom.
SOLUTION
- Use a silpat instead of parchment paper (explained in detail below).
- Pipe at a 45° angle, while exerting constant pressure, when you’re piping the middle of the eclair.
- Make sure the middle of your piped eclair is NOT thicker than the two ends (i.e. it should be dog bone-shaped).
Silpat vs parchment paper
I came about this little discovery quite by accident. I’m not entirely sure what it is about a silpat (besides it having something to do with heat conduction), but eclairs baked on a silpat are always more stable and neat than those baked on parchment paper.
If you don’t have a silpat, that is OK, you can still use parchment paper. But I usually add fewer eggs to my choux pastry if I know I’m baking chocolate eclairs on parchment paper.
Parchment paper (top) vs Silpat (bottom)
Piping at a 45 degree angle, on the silpat mat
This is the best angle to pipe your choux pastry at constant pressure, with minimal distortions on the piped choux. If you pipe from the top (like with profiteroles), it puts too much pressure on the choux, pushing/crushing it against the tray, and this may cause your eclairs to puff up horizontally, rather than vertically.
I also like to make sure the piping tip makes contact with the silpat (at a 45° angle), as I pipe the choux. It helps form a stable base for the eclairs, while also giving you some stability to pipe evenly, with consistent pressure.
Eclairs piped in a dog bone shape, that are narrower in the middle.
Consistent piping pressure and shape
Inconsistent or varying piping pressure will result in lumpy eclairs that aren’t as clean or professional-looking as you’d like. This is especially more problematic if you pipe extra dough in the middle compared to the ends. The middle will then puff up more, and you’ll end up with oval-shaped eclairs that are more inclined to collapse as well.
This is why I prefer to pipe just a little extra dough at the ends (i.e. dog bone-shaped). But you can also pipe them nice and straight, where the ends are only slightly larger than the middle. Either way, you will end up with beautiful, even, and incredibly delicious eclair shells, that are guaranteed to never collapse or flatten!
Eclairs piped with just a little extra dough at the ends (to prevent oval shaped eclairs)
My eclairs have large cracks on top.
This often happens when the dough isn’t prepared properly, and you have undissolved salt or sugar in it.
Another reason is baking it in a high temperature oven.
You also tend to get more cracks if you pipe with a round tip instead of a star tip. This is likely because of the increased surface area that you get when piped with a star tip, which gives the choux pastry more leeway to expand.
See below for differences between eclairs piped with a round tip, open star tip, and a French star tip. You can see that the French star tip yields the neatest eclair pastry shell, and the round tip eclair has an uneven shape with more cracks.
SOLUTION
- Use a French star tip (instead of a round tip). If you only have a round tip, then you can use a fork to gently scrape/mark lines on the top of your piped dough to increase the surface area.
- Make sure the sugar and salt are completely dissolved in the water.
- Do not add raw flour to the dough.
- Lower the oven temperature (if you’re baking at 400°F or higher), and bake for longer at a lower oven temperature (375°F) instead.
Difference in eclair shells piped using different tips. The round tip (top) has the most cracks, and the French star tip (bottom) has the least cracks on the surface.
Now I will take you through a detailed, step by step guide on this classic eclair recipe.
If you’re new to making eclairs, or you’re having trouble perfecting your chocolate eclairs, please read the post carefully. These tips will help you make absolutely perfect, beautiful eclair shells every single time! 🙂
Recommended equipment
Half sheet baking trays – at least two. I prefer baking one tray at a time, to get consistently good results. If you do want to bake two trays at a time, that is fine too, but remember TO NOT OPEN THE OVEN BEFORE THE 25 MINUTE MARK.
Silpat mats – highly recommended, especially for classic eclairs (chocolate eclairs). Provides better heat conduction, and helps the eclairs rise in an even and stable way. If you don’t have silpat mats, you can use parchment paper, but be mindful of the choux pastry consistency.
French star tip (1/2 inch diameter) – the grooves in the star tip create a “raked” dough that prevents the eclair shells from cracking as they expand. You can use a round tip as well, but in that case, use a fork and drag it lightly along the surface of the piped dough to make multiple, long lines (to mimic the pattern that you’d get with a star tip). You can use an open star tip too, but a French star tip is the best option.
Choux pastry
Weigh your ingredients. I use a basic kitchen scale to weigh the wet ingredients as well. I simply place the saucepan on the kitchen scale, and weigh the water, then butter, and then add the salt and sugar.
You can either use just water, or milk, or a mixture of water and milk.
Stir while heating to make sure the salt and sugar dissolve, and the butter dissolves BEFORE the mix comes to a boil.
When the mix comes to a boil, remove the saucepan from the heat and add ALL OF THE SIFTED FLOUR in one go. Stir to bring it together and form a dough. Make sure there are no lumps in your dough, and then return the saucepan to the stove and cook the dough for about 2-3 minutes while mixing vigorously. This is important because you want the excess water to evaporate. You’ll know it’s done, when there’s a film of dough forming at the bottom of your saucepan. Plus, if you stick a spoon in the dough, it should stay upright.
Allow the choux pastry dough to cool down in a large bowl, until the temperature registers at under 160°F. I spread the choux pastry dough along the wall of the bowl when doing this, so that more steam escapes and the dough cools down faster.
Addition of eggs
This part is important. Add the eggs a little at a time, until your dough just starts to get a glossy sheen. This means you may end up using all the eggs, or only a portion of it. I usually end up adding 3 1/2 eggs, or sometimes 4 (if I had to cook the dough longer, which results in a drier dough).
As you mix in the eggs at the beginning, the dough will be a slimy mess, but as you incorporate more eggs, it’ll become smoother, and runnier, and start to get a sheen.
Stop adding eggs as soon as the dough reaches this point where it gets a sheen (or looks a little glossy), and isn’t too runny. There are 2 ways to check for the correct consistency of your glossy choux pastry dough.
- Drag your finger along the surface of the choux pastry dough to create a trough. The sides of this trough should stay upright and not collapse into the dough. If they do, it’s because the dough is too runny.
- Place a rubber spatula in the dough, upright, and then stir the dough with it a little, and slowly lift the spatula, straight up. If the dough forms a V shape at the end of the spatula (as shown in the picture in the post), then it’s also the right consistency.
Personally, I prefer the first method, but either method is effective.
Piping choux pastry dough
When the choux pastry dough is ready, transfer it into a large pastry bag (I use a 16 inch pastry bag), with a 1/2 inch wide French star tip.
If it’s easier, you can cut a 4-5 inch piece of cardboard or a wooden skewer and use that as a guide to pipe eclairs of equal length. Or you can simply eye ball it too.
Pipe 4-5 inch long choux pastry cases on the prepared baking tray (with a silpat mat), leaving 2 inches of space between each. I pipe about 8-10 eclairs on each half sheet baking tray. Remember to keep the piping bag at a 45° angle as discusses above, and maintain consistent piping pressure. Make the ends of your piped choux cases slightly larger than in the middle.
Finish off each piped case by gently twisting the piping tip. This helps prevent the entire piped choux case lifting up along with the piping tip. This will also create a pointed or jagged end. So using a damp finger, pat down those pointed ends of your choux cases.
Dust each eclair case with confectioner’s sugar. This creates a slightly caramelized exterior that not only adds a slight sweetness, but also a delightful crunch.
Baking classic eclairs
Bake in a preheated oven for 25-30 minutes, until the choux cases have turned light brown in color. Then quickly open the oven door, and carefully prick each eclair case on one end with a toothpick to release the air inside. The eclairs should have formed a brown crust by this point. This is important, because if you prick them before the crust has formed, the choux cases will collapse.
Close the oven door and bake for a further 5-10 minutes (I usually bake for a further 8 minutes), until the cases have turned darker brown in color (but not burnt!).
Baked eclair cases piped with slightly larger ends, so that you don’t end up with misshapen or oval-shaped eclair cases.
Remove from the oven and prick the other end of your choux cases, and let them cool down completely in a draft free area. I keep it on top of the oven or near the oven, where it’s a little warmer and draft-free. This way there’s no risk of the choux cases cooling down too fast and collapsing.
When the eclairs have cooled down, they are ready to be filled with your choice of filling. I typically use vanilla pastry cream, or chocolate pastry cream, or cream diplomat for a lighter option.
What can I fill my classic eclairs with?
Usually, classic chocolate eclairs have a creamy vanilla pastry cream filling. It’s almost like a vanilla pudding, with a prominent vanilla flavor, and not too sweet.
But you can also fill your chocolate eclairs with a delicious chocolate pastry cream too.
However, if you’d like a lighter filling than pastry cream (cream patisserie), then you can try cream diplomat or cream chantilly (sweetened whipped cream) instead.
From top to bottom: vanilla pastry cream, chocolate pastry cream, vanilla diplomat cream, chocolate diplomat cream
Here, I made FOUR different fillings for my classic chocolate eclairs.
- Vanilla pastry cream
- Chocolate pastry cream
- Vanilla diplomat cream (vanilla pastry cream + cream chantilly). This tastes like a melt in your mouth vanilla ice cream but lighter and not cold.
- Chocolate diplomat cream (chocolate pastry cream + cream Chantilly). This tastes like a light, melt in your mouth chocolate ice cream and not cold.
You have 2 ways of filling these classic eclairs.
- With a bismarck tip. Insert the tip from the ends of the eclair and fill it from both ends. Once filled, wipe the ends to remove excess filling.
- Use a star tip (small opening) and make 3 holes on the bottom of the eclair shell. Use the same small tip (or a round tip), to fill the eclair from the bottom. Wipe to remove any excess filling.
The second method is my favorite, even though I do own a bismarck tip as well.
Dipping chocolate eclairs in chocolate glaze
Once all the eclairs are filled, then it’s time to dip them in the chocolate glaze for chocolate eclairs. The chocolate glaze is really easy to make, and super delicious on its own. It’s just a mixture of chocolate, cream, butter, and a touch of corn syrup.
The simple trick to getting beautifully glazed chocolate eclairs is to DIP them in the glaze, rather than pouring the glaze over the eclairs.
Carefully and evenly dip each eclair in the warm chocolate glaze. Then gently turn it in the glaze to get an even coating. Once coated, gently shake it to allow excess chocolate glaze to drip down into the bowl again. Using a paper towel or toothpick, wipe off any excess chocolate glaze along the edges of your chocolate eclair. Then place it on a wire rack and allow the glaze to set.
For best results, serve these chocolate eclairs at room temp, or chilled, right away, OR within 12 hours of filling.
The chocolate eclairs will lose their crispiness after they’ve been filled. However, since the shells are baked till they are dark golden brown in color, they form a sturdy shell that doesn’t get soggy by the filling. But the longer you go after filling your eclairs, the softer the shells will get (but they shouldn’t get soggy even after 24 hours).
Can I make chocolate eclairs ahead of time?
You can make the shells, filling, and glaze separately, and store them separately until needed.
The best way to store eclairs is as unfilled shells. Unfilled baked eclair shells can be stored in an air-tight container for up to 1 month in the freezer. When you’re ready, simply thaw them out at room temp., fill, glaze, and they are ready to be devoured!
Can I store filled eclairs?
You can, but I’m a little reluctant to say that. It’s not ideal. But understandable. You made eclairs and have leftovers. You want to know how to store them right?
Keep these filled eclairs on a parchment paper lined tray, in a single layer. Do not stack them. Let them freeze for about one hour. Once frozen, place them in an air-tight container, in layers if needed, separating each layer with parchment paper. Then put them back in the freezer. Filled eclairs can be kept for about 4 days like this. But they do lose their freshness with time.
To defrost, keep the eclairs at room temp. for about 1 hour until they thaw out, and then they are ready to be served.
Unfilled eclair shells – can be frozen in an air-tight container for up to 1 month.
Pastry cream – can be refrigerated for up to 3 days. Make sure it’s in an air-tight container, with a plastic wrap touching the surface of the custard.
Chocolate glaze – can be stored for up to 1 week in the fridge.
Filled and glazed eclairs – for up to 4 days in the freezer (maybe even longer, but the eclairs will continue to lose freshness with time).
Timeline for making these classic chocolate eclairs
The day before:
Make 1 1/2 batches of the vanilla pastry cream or chocolate pastry cream. OR make 1 batch of each, if you’d like a mix of vanilla and chocolate.
You can also make the choux pastry dough on the day before as well, and store it in a pastry bag, inside an air-tight plastic container.
On the day you’re serving the chocolate eclairs:
Bake the eclairs (or you can bake them ahead of time and freeze as well).
While the eclairs are cooling, prepare the pastry cream by transferring it into pastry bags. Also, prepare the chocolate glaze and keep it warm.
Fill the eclairs, and dip each one in the chocolate glaze as you go. Let the chocolate glaze set. Chill for a few hours if needed, and serve.
If you liked this classic eclair recipe (chocolate eclair recipe), don’t forget to subscribe for new (and free) recipes by entering your email address in the subscription box below the recipe card (and get all these recipes delivered straight to your inbox), so you don’t miss out on a thing. You can find me on FACEBOOK, TWITTER, INSTAGRAM, PINTEREST, YOU TUBE and GOOGLE-PLUS too.
Other recipes you may like to check out
Craquelin Choux Pastry with Salted Caramel filling
EQUIPMENT I USED FOR THIS RECIPE
Piping bags – 16 inch piping bags for the choux pastry dough
French star pastry tip with 1/2 inch opening – to pipe the eclair cases.
Whisks – A good set of whisks is a must for all of your baking needs.
Hand mixer or Stand Mixer – I currently use KitchenAid
2 x Silpat baking mats – highly recommended for foolrpoof
2 x Half Sheet pans – Having two makes it easier to bake the craquelin choux pastry. While one is baking, the other tray can cool down and be ready to pipe dough on, and then bake as soon as the other tray is out.
Looking for more recipes?Sign up for my free recipe newsletter to get new recipes in your inbox each week! Find me sharing more inspiration on Pinterest and Instagram.
Classic Chocolate Eclairs
What You Need:
- See the post for a list of recommended tools & equipment
Ingredients:
Choux Pastry for the Eclairs
- 8 fl oz water
- 4 oz unsalted butter
- ½ tsp kosher salt use less, if you’re using fine salt or table salt
- 1 tbsp granulated white sugar
- 5 oz bread flour sifted (or AP flour, I prefer bread flour for eclairs)
- 1 tsp vanilla extract optional
- 8 oz eggs about 4 large eggs
Filling for the Eclairs
Chocolate Glaze
- 12 oz semisweet chocolate
- 6 fl oz whipping cream ¾ cup
- A generous pinch of kosher salt
- 2 tbsp unsalted butter
- 2 tbsp corn syrup optional
Instructions:
Choux Pastry
- Preheat oven to 375°F.
- Place the water, butter, salt and sugar in a medium-sized saucepan and heat over medium heat while stirring occasionally. (Make sure the salt and sugar dissolve completely in the warm water, and the butter melts BEFORE the water comes to a boil).
- As soon as the water comes to a boil (with a few bubbles breaking through the surface), move the pot away from the stove and add all of the sifted flour into the boiling liquid. Using a wooden spoon or a heat-proof silicone spatula, stir the mixture vigorously to allow the flour to absorb all the water and form a ball of dough, and remove any flour clumps in the dough.
- After about 45 - 60 seconds of mixing, return the saucepan to the stove (with medium heat), and let the dough cook for a further 2 - 3 minutes while stirring and mixing. Do this until you see a film of dough forming on the bottom of your saucepan (please note that this only occurs with stainless steel saucepans, not in non-stick saucepans).
- Remove the saucepan from the heat and transfer the dough into a large mixing bowl. Mix the dough gently, for about 2 - 3 minutes, to release the steam and to let it cool down (lower than 160°F). Alternatively, you can flatten the dough along the wall of the mixing bowl and let it cool down for a few minutes.
- Crack all the eggs into a jug and whisk well to combine.
- When the dough has cooled down, mix in the vanilla (I don’t use vanilla, but you can if you like). Next add the eggs in 5 - 6 additions, mixing each addition well into the dough before adding more. You can use a stand mixer or a spatula to mix in the eggs. Stop adding eggs when the dough starts to get a sheen, and looks glossy. Please read the post for more details. Then check for the right dough consistency with the choux pastry test (detailed in the post).
- Place the dough in a 16 inch pastry bag and secure the bag opening, and set it aside until you get the baking trays ready. Line a baking tray with a silpat mat. Also have a bowl of water and a bowl of confectioner’s sugar with a small mesh strainer ready as well.
- Fit a different pastry bag with a ½ inch French star tip. Then snip the end off of the choux pastry bag from the previous step, and place that in the bag with the French star tip.
- Hold the pastry bag at a 45° angle, with the French star tip touching the silpat. Pipe 8 - 10 eclairs (4 - 5 inches in length) on the silpat lined baking tray. When piping, make sure the ends are a little larger than the middle portion of the eclairs. Twist the piping tip at the end so that you end with a slightly pointed/jagged end.
- Dip your finger in water and pat the ends of the eclairs to flatten the pointed ends. Sift some confectioner’s sugar over the eclairs.
- Place the baking tray in the middle rack of your oven, and set the timer to 25 minutes. After 25 minutes, check if the eclairs have turned golden brown. If they have, then open the oven door and quickly prick each of the eclairs with a sharp toothpick or skewer on one end.
- Close the oven door and let the eclairs bake for a further 5 - 10 minutes until they turn a darker golden color. You want the eclairs to be baked a little longer so that they hold their shape better.
- Remove them from the oven, and immediately prick the eclair cases on the other end. Let them cool down for about 10 minutes on the baking tray and then transfer them onto a wire rack.
- Pipe more eclairs on the second silpat lined baking tray and bake. Repeat until you have used up all of your choux pastry.
- Once the eclairs have cooled down, they are ready to be filled. If you’re filling them later, place the unfilled shells in an air-tight container and freeze for later.
Filling
- Make vanilla pastry cream or chocolate pastry cream according to the linked recipes, the day before, and let it chill in the fridge overnight.
- Place the filling of your choice in a 16 inch pastry bag, with a small round tip (5 - 10mm in diameter).
- Use a French star tip or the round tip to carefully make 3 holes on the bottom of your eclair shells. Fill the eclair shells with with pastry cream through these holes.
- Wipe off any excess pastry cream. Repeat with all the eclair shells.
Chocolate Glaze
- Place the chocolate chips in a large, microwave-safe bowl.
- Heat the cream and salt in a separate bowl in the microwave or a saucepan. When the cream starts to simmer, immediately pour it over the chocolate chips. Add the corn syrup and butter. Stir the chocolate chips until they have completely melted and you have a glossy chocolate glaze. If the chocolate isn’t completely melted after stirring, microwave for 10 - 20 second bursts to melt the chocolate completely.
- Dip each filled eclair in the chocolate glaze (read the post for more details on how to cleanly glaze your chocolate eclairs).
- Place the glazed eclairs on a wire rack and allow the chocolate glaze to set.
- Serve at room temperature, or chilled.
Tips & Tricks
Nutrition Information:
“This website provides approximate nutrition information for convenience and as a courtesy only. Nutrition data is gathered primarily from the USDA Food Composition Database, whenever available, or otherwise other online calculators.”
Leanne says
One question, can I pipe them, freeze, and then baking the eclairs the next day?
I am baking a lot for a crowd and this would help immensely.
Dini says
Hi Leanne
I haven’t done this myself, but I have had readers who have. They said that they did get good results.
Just make sure that you prevent freezer burn and wrap the tray as soon as the piped dough is frozen.
Nil says
I love your website. I really do ans you’ve answered aaaaallll of my questions! Thanks for that. But I have one question which is unanswered; what oven mode is good for choux pastry? I heard that convection doesn’t work for it. Is that true? Thanks again❤️
Dini says
Hi Nil
I’m glad that you found this post useful 🙂
It won’t matter if you use a convection or conventional oven to make choux pastry. Professional kitchens more likely than not would have convection ovens, and culinary schools have convection ovens as well!
The main thing is to adjust the oven temperature and bake time accordingly. I’ve baked choux pastry in different ovens, and with each oven I’ve had to make adjustments to get the right results. With convection, you have three options – either reduce the heat by 25 F or bake it for a shorter time at the same temperature or even a combination of the two. One sacrificial batch might be needed to find out what settings will work best in your oven.
I hope that helps!
Nil says
It’s about 12 hours that I’m reading your posts and I enjoyed all of them and
Thanks for your answer ❤️
Raeesah says
Thank you for the wonderful recipe and all the extra info my eclairs were a resounding success. Absolutely as explained and most delicious. Thank you 🙂
Dini says
That’s fantastic Raeesah, I’m so glad they came out well! 🙂
Katya says
Hi! Do you use imperial or US fluid oz in the recipe?
Dini says
Hi Katya,
All volume measurements in the recipe are US measurements. But you can also access metric measurements by using the toggle button under the ingredients list. I hope that helps!
Mano says
Thank you for such a detailed foolproof recipe..I’ve only tried this recipe and haven’t tried any other and it comes out perfect every single time! ❤️
Betty Cox says
Thanks for the detailed instructions, I will be trying this recipe for a birthday party this weekend.
Jay says
Do you have any options for eggless eclairs?
Dini says
Hi Jay
I do highly recommend following a recipe that is specifically for eggless eclairs or vegan eclairs so you would get better results.
Luaipou Walshe says
Can I use baking paper instead?
Dini says
Hi Luaipou
You can use parchment paper! I’m not sure if baking paper is the same as parchment paper. You get best results with a silpat, but you will still get good eclairs with parchment paper too
First timer says
Should you still get the silpat wet as you do with parchment paper?
Dini says
Hi
You can spray with water whether you use parchment paper or silpat, and this is an optional step. But for eclairs I personally prefer to sift confectioners sugar over the shells (as noted in the recipe).
payal gupta says
Can you pls suggest the egg replacement in this recipe.. I really wanna try try this but eggfree.
Dini says
Hi Payal
Eggs are very important in this recipe for structure and for rise. I couldn’t recommend on what you can use to replace the eggs in this recipe that will still give the correct final results. I recommend searching for a vegan choux pastry recipe and pastry cream recipe with good reviews so that you know it will work without eggs.
Autumn says
These are the best eclairs I’ve ever made! I wish I found this recipe sooner
Irena says
Hi Dini,
Thank you so much for the detailed and thorough post. Knowing all the minute details that a principal to perfect eclairs helped me though the process of making gluten free batter and baking process reliable. The most valuable advice was about the texture of the batter and the tip to use two bags for piping. The conditions for baking in my case very 180C fan forced and baking paper. May be silicone mat would be as good as baking paper, but I used them at 190C and 185C, that forced me to bake 24+6 minutes, or 25+7 minutes. However slight splitting of the batter Can be attributed to the absence of gluten, not compensated by any gums, only using 3 eggs and 2 egg whites to the total weight of 232g.
Thanks again!!!
ılgaz sarıyar says
ı like ıt
Sam says
I am preparing to make this recipe (looking very much forward to it!) and noticed the French star tip you linked to is 0.6875″, but you say in the recipe to use a 0.5″ French star tip for piping the choux pastry. Could you clarify what size the French star tip should be? Thanks!
Dini says
Hi Sam
You can use a 0.5 or 0.6 inch piping tip. The 0.1″ difference won’t make a huge difference.
I hope that helps!
Megan says
Complete success following this recipe, including the Choux pastry guide and tips and tricks. So well explained and very happy with the results. I will be using this recipe again and again! Thank you for posting it.
Dini says
Thank you so much Megan! I’m so glad the information helped and you had success with this recipe! 🙂
Sab says
Followed the recipe exactly but it was raw from the inside. The outside shell is perfect though. Tried twice now and same issue. Even baking for longer didn’t help. Any idea why this could be
Dini says
Hi Sab
It sounds like the dough is too thick and heavy and isn’t rising properly.
You may need to add more eggs to get the right consistency so that the pastry is light enough to rise while baking and create a hollow center.
Willow says
I’ve made eclairs before from a different recipe but never knew I was missing out on so much more! I was doing so many mistakes before and this helped me perfect the texture, shape, and flavor of the eclairs. I’m super grateful!! Thank you for this detailed recipe.
Dini says
I’m really glad the recipe and the information helped Willow! 🙂 Thank you so much for letting me know!
Willow says
Quick question. Would it be alright to make double to triple the recipe in one go? Or would be best to make it one batch at a time?
Dini says
Hi Willow
You can make multiple batches, but follow the same techniques to ensure you get the right consistency.
I do prefer to bake one tray a time in my conventional oven, so the extra dough will have to be stored properly while each tray is being baked. This means to keep the dough in a pastry bag or cover the surface of the dough with plastic wrap to prevent a skin from forming on the dough.
Willow says
Got it. Thank you so much! 🙂
Preethi says
Can I use parchment paper instead of Silpat mat
Preethi says
Hi mam today I tried ur recipe.. it was yummy..
Diz was my 1st try
I hv few doubt
1. After I fill the cream it becomes little soggy
2. If I want to sell elclairs when to fill the creams
Please help me mam
Rudy says
Hi! What happens if I put 2 layers of parchment paper on the baking sheet? Is it bad and will it make any difference as opposed to just 1 layer of parchment paper?
Dini says
Hi Rudy
That shouldn’t make a difference. At least I don’t think it could create any negative impacts.
I hope that helps!
Kait says
Hi! I’m planning on making this tomorrow at 6 am. We will be having dessert at 9 pm. How should I store these until then so it’s still crispy & delicious? Thanks!
Dini says
Hi Kait
I’m sorry for the late reply.
You can make these in the morning and keep them unfilled in an air tight container, until you’re ready to fill and serve them.
You could fill them a few hours in advance, but choux pastry is going to be less crisp (not soggy). This is OK, because it’s just the way an eclair works.
I hope that helps!
CD says
I have a question, im going to be using parchment paper and I was wondering up to what point should I stop adding the eggs? I read that when you use parchment paper you use less eggs. So how many eggs should I add into the mix when using parchment paper?
Dini says
Hi CD
I’m not sure if the egg content will make a difference between using parchment paper vs silpat. I found the piping technique made more of a difference than the texture of the dough. I recommend still preparing the dough the same way, and making sure it’s glossy and pipeable.
I hope that helps
Tas says
I really enjoyed making this recipe, but some od my eclairs juat sink from the bottom. Was not able to fill them. Please help me
Dini says
Hi Tas
I have addressed this issue in my post as well. You can read the section about eclairs with sunken bottoms. I’ve explained reasons as to why this could happen and what has helped me prevent this issue.
I hope that helps!
Nour says
Hi Dini. I have tried many recipes for eclair, but I would like to try your eclair recipe to see which was best and to see the difference between the other recipes. I just wanted to ask you that when we bake the eclairs do we put the oven with fan or without fan? I am asking you so that i would make sure the temperature is right and that the time suits it so that it is cooked correctly. Please let me know if we put the oven with fan or without when baking the eclairs.
Thank you
Dini says
Hi Nour
I always bake in a conventional oven without the fan function. I usually prefer to do all my baking without the fan, because the results have been more consistent without the fan forcing the air inside the oven.
I hope that helps.
Enosha says
I’ve only baked a butter cake and decided during this time to go to the extreme . It was like a science experiment for me but thanks to your foolproof recipe the result felt like I was sitting at a pastry shop along the Seine eating eclairs with vanilla pastry cream . Scrumptious!
Now to try your fudgiest one bowl choc cake !
Ash says
This recipe is great!! Mine were a little messy, and I had to use a round tip with fork but they still look amazing! I did have to bake them for about 40 minutes though, and even then after I put the three holes in I had to put them back in the oven because there was raw dough inside.
Kayla H says
Can I use a different size tip? I don’t have the French star tip.
Dini says
Hi Kayla
The french tip is the best for eclairs, but you can use the round tip too. You can see the pictures in the post that compare the pastry results using round tip, french star tip and an open star tip. I also have used a fork to make light markings along the piped dough (if I use a round tip), which also helps to mimic the troughs from a french star tip.
I hope that helps!
Caroline M says
Finally…. success!!!
I got beautiful crispy fluffy eclairs after many many failed attempts previously.
Thank you so much!!!
Diana says
This is a fantastic article/recipe and well written.
The tips are very useful.
Thank you for this!
Sunny Lee says
amazing! Never seen this much of detailed recipe. Thank you so so much. Mine came out 90% great, just need to get used to my oven. Again, Thank you!!
Natti says
I love this so much !
Susan Demarest says
Excellent tutorial and recipe. My eclairs turned out beautifully and were delicious! Many thanks.
Jen Dou says
Hello! Very great I instructions, but I must have gone wrong somewhere! My pastry has risen and looks perfect on the outside but it a little doughy on the inside. Where do you think I’ve gone wrong? Should I turn the temp down on the over and cook for a little longer so that the inside cooks? Let me know what you think! Thank you 🙂
Dini says
Hi Jen!
This can happen if the dough was too stiff as well. But yes, absolutely try letting the dough dry out in the oven for a little longer. You can prick the cases during the last 5 minutes of bake time to let the insides dry out a little as well.
Emma Bridges says
Great detailed instructions – thank you. My eclairs turned out perfectly. I cooked them on gas 7 for 10 minutes before turning the oven down to 5 for 20 minutes and the results are delicious!
Lindsay says
Perfect! Made these today!
ehud levi says
thank you for the reciepe.
perfect and detailed reciepe.
i have to ask, is it possible to replace the water with milk?
Dini says
Hi Ehud
Thank you!
And yes, you can replace the water with milk. Milk makes for a softer shell, compared to water. Hope that helps 🙂
Sherry G Smith says
I have to make this recipe for my culinary class tomorrow. I enjoyed reading the steps and tips. You helped me understand the whole recipe even better. Thanks
Gregory Joseph Farrell says
A+ for including all the steps and troubleshooting comments. I made these today for a french cafe I supply pies to and they came out okay. I live at 7,300ft in elevation so many times I have to adjust recipes for fat content. The hardest part of this recipe was getting the dough inside my pastry bag without my hands slipping. I have a reusable rubber bag. The other problem I had was making too much of the chocolate topping. I didn’t have semi-sweet chocolate chips so I made the dip with cocoa powder, sugar, cream and butter. It came out okay, but I have enough left over to put on my ice cream sundaes for a month. The flavor and the consistency of the eclairs make this a recipe I will keep in my forever folder. Thank you.
Alicia says
The recipe and tips are perfection! I tried a couple of different recipes (without great success and with much frustration) before I stumbled onto this one. I love that the the ingredients are measured by weight and I think that’s one of the reasons why this recipe makes perfect eclairs. Thank-you!
Grayce says
Oh my,….seriously Dini this is such a fantastic recipe. Made them! LOVED them. You are a genius and THANK YOU so much for sharing this great recipe. This one gets 100% from me. Utter PER-FEC-TION!!!!
Jayne says
Absolutely FANTASTIC! The step by step instructions made it so much easier. Best recipe I have found. Many thanks xx
Dini says
Thank you so much for letting me know Jayne. I’m so glad the step by step instructions helped, and you enjoyed the recipe! 🙂
Linda Bull says
Thank you for saying 8oz of eggs. Large eggs are not uniform in size or weight and I do prefer to use duck eggs when incorporating into strong flour. Perfect results but had 35 years of practice. Christmas is coming gifts are to be made ! Thank you
Cristina says
Can you make the Choux pastry dough ahead of time and then bake it later?
Dini says
Hi Cristina!
I do sometimes leave my choux pastry dough in the piping bag (completely covered from the air) up to 24 hours in advance in the fridge. I have also had some readers tell me that they have piped the choux pastry, and then frozen it on a sheet pan covered with plastic wrap, and then baked it and had good results too. I haven’t tried this myself though, so I’m not sure how good the results are from experience. Hope that helps!
Diane says
Your recipes look great
Joan says
Thanks for the recipe! Since weighing is always the best way to measure accurately (as you say), can you update the recipe to
include weights?
Dini says
Hi Joan!
Yes, measuring by weight is obviously the most accurate way, which is why I have already included weight measurements in the recipe card. The metric option is available just below the ingredients list (US customary-Metric toggle button). Hope that helps!
Ha na says
My.. oh my…
You have a great explanation. Really helpful.
Thanks for share your choux-venture.
Ah, i just have 1 problem. I’m live in Indonesia, so unfamiliar with degree fahrenheit
Actually, usually bake my choux at 220-250′ C. Sometimes it hild its shape. But, sometimes, the botton sink
I’ll take your advice for my next attempt. Thanks again.
Regards,
Ha na
Mario says
Indonesia. Nice! The conversion from F to C is to take the temperature in F, subtract 32, divide it by 9 and then multiply by 5. So, for this recipe, the temperature given is 375F. To convert, calculate (375-32)/9*5 = 190.55 Celcius.
Kim says
190 C.
Aminta says
They came out perfectly! Choux pastry was always hit and miss for me….and so I decided to try your recipe. The trouble shooting post is fabulous because it tells me exactly what to look out for. Thanks so much I will never use another recipe again.
Dini says
Yay, I’m so glad you liked the recipe and the tips helped Aminta! 🙂 Thank you so much for letting me know!
Candy says
Five stars!! Your instructions were detailed and instructive, thank you for sharing your knowledge, so wondefully selfless of you!!
I made these for an anniversary party today and they were a hit, and professional in appearance. Many thanks and blessings to you
Ros @ ZenHealth says
Bookmarked! Definitely will be trying this for Mother’s Day weekend!
Baguio Restaurants by Mae says
Gonna try the chocolate cream filling since I’m a self proclaimed chocolate addict hahaha! These chocolate eclairs are making my tummy go hungry. Thank you for sharing this recipe in detailed step by step procedure and also the helpful tips.
Samantha says
Thank you for such a scrumptious recipe and for such detailed tips and tricks to ensure success!
Ritz says
Can I use oil Instead of butter ?
Dini says
Hi Ritz!
I haven’t tried making eclairs with oil before. It might still turn out well, but the texture and flavor might be different though.
Bea says
I have made eclairs before, however your recipe is the very best that I have used! Thank you so much for sharing, my shells were perfect in size, shape, color.
wilhelmina says
Eclairs are my Mom’s favorite dessert, so I am always on the lookout for great recipes. This one is a definite keeper!
Karly says
Great step by step! Thanks for sharing!