Don’t like firm, jellied cranberry filling in your pie? I got you! This cranberry pie has a perfectly juicy yet thick pie filling paired with an incredibly flaky, buttery all butter pie crust!
I pre-cook the cranberry filling to create a chunky, jammy cranberry sauce-like consistency which I LOVE. I also go easy on the spices so that the tangy, tart, fruity cranberry flavor is the STAR in this pie! Plus, you can make it with fresh or frozen cranberries, and the pie freezes beautifully since I use tapioca starch as the thickener here.

I’ve been making pumpkin pie and butterscotch apple pie (and the occasional caramel banana cream pie) for Thanksgiving for AGES. Curiously though, I had never let seasonal cranberries don that pie crown on my Thanksgiving table. This year, I decided to change that.
And I can safely say, we now have a Thanksgiving star, and it’s this cranberry pie! Juicy, sweet, tart, and encased in the butteriest, flakiest pie crust. And as a bonus, those ruby red cranberries make my heart so happy with their bright pop of color! 😊
Why this recipe works

- I tested this recipe with fresh AND frozen cranberries, so you can use either option and still get perfect results.
- The cranberry flavor is the highlight, with just a hint of spice to elevate the overfall flavor profile!
- The pie is sweet, but not overly sweet. The fresh, fruity, tart cranberry flavor is still the star.
- The pie filling is perfectly juicy, as I pre-cook the filling. It doesn’t have the texture of firm, jellied cranberry (which I’m not a fan of) that you get with most recipes, but instead contains juicy, jammy consistency!
- My tried and true all butter pie crust pairs perfectly with the cranberry filling.
This cranberry pie came to be because of my craving for sour cherry pie! But I couldn’t find any sour cherries (fresh, frozen, or canned) anywhere near me. So instead, I made a sweet cherry pie, but replaced some of the cherries with tart cranberries!
The flavor was incredible, and a new idea was planted in my head to make a bona-fide cranberry pie!
Ingredients you’ll need

- Cranberries
- Sugar
- Tapioca starch
- Orange juice
- Orange zest
- Spices
- Allspice
- Ground ginger
- Salt
Cranberries
You can use fresh or frozen cranberries in this recipe. Plus, you don’t have to thaw frozen cranberries either since we’ll be pre-cooking most of the cranberries to get the best cranberry pie filling! This lets you balance the texture and flavor of the filling.
When choosing fresh cranberries, make sure the cranberries are a deep red color, and very firm to the touch. Avoid cranberries that are mushy or have any softened spots on them.
Spices
I only use allspice and ginger in this recipe. That’s because I want the taste of cranberries to be the absolute star in this pie! The spices add some warmth, without overpowering the overall flavor.
However, you can also add other spices such as cinnamon or cardamom OR more of allspice and ginger if you like. The amount and type of spices you add will depend largely on what your preferences are.
I’ve made this recipe with different combinations and amounts of warming spices, but I always come back to a simple spice profile because I want it to complement the cranberry flavor, instead of overpowering it.
Thickeners
Cranberries are very high in pectin, so they will thicken the pie filling naturally too! The setting strength of the pectin is activated by the sugar that you add. So I don’t recommend using sugar substitutes or reducing the amount of sugar in this recipe.
Because of the pectin, the cranberry filling can set like a firm gel. I’m not the biggest fan of this texture, so I had to figure out how to get a juicy filling that isn’t too firm, but also not runny.
The addition of orange juice, some tapioca starch, AND pre-cooking the filling helped me achieve this texture and flavor!

Workflow for cranberry pie
There are several way to organize your workflow when making this pie.
You can make the cranberry pie filling ahead of time. Since it’s partially cooked, I find it easier to cook the filling first, and then let it chill in the fridge overnight. This is for convenience, since you can make the filling just a few hours before making the pie too (the filling can be chilled or used warm).
You can also make the pie dough ahead of time and chill it in the fridge.
One day before (or up to 3 days ahead of time)
- Make the cranberry pie filling. Cook the filling and let it chill in the fridge. You can also add the extra chopped cranberries at the same time.
- Make the pie dough and let it chill and rest in the fridge.
The night before (or within 24 hours of serving)
- Make the pie filling (if you didn’t before). It can be used while warm and doesn’t need to be chilled before adding it to the pie dish.
- Roll out the dough and line the pie plate.
- Fill and cover the pie.
- Bake and then cool down to room temperature (so that the filling sets properly).
- Serve.

Why I like to cook my cranberry filling
When I make cranberry pie with whole cranberries without cooking them, the result is generally good, but it usually has more whole or chopped cranberries in the filling.
In contrast, I MUCH prefer a cranberry sauce that has chunky cranberries with a jammy texture! So, by cooking some of the cranberries, I get that amazing jammy texture in the filling.
I achieve this texture by stirring the cranberries as they break down, AND by folding in more chopped cranberries into the cooked filling that keep their shape while they bake. This is similar to how I make my cherry pie filling for homemade cherry pie as well.
I also add orange juice to the filling because cooking it allows me to add extra liquids that will concentrate a little during this pre-cooking stage.
This way, you get the best of both worlds, and end up with the BEST texture and flavor in your cranberry pie filling!
How to make cranberry pie (step by step overview)
Step 1 – Make the pie dough (from scratch or store-bought)
I prefer to make my own pie dough using my all butter pie crust recipe. You can use store-bought pie dough as well. However, this recipe is a for a deep dish cranberry pie, so you may need more dough than the standard store-bought pie dough to line the pie plate.
Step 2 – Prepare cranberries for the filling
You can use frozen of fresh cranberries for the filling. You don’t have to thaw out frozen cranberries before using, because we’ll be cooking most of the cranberries for this.
If you’re using fresh cranberries, make sure to use firm, bright red cranberries. Avoid any that are mushy, or have soft / discolored spots.
Wash and allow the excess water to drain from the cranberries.
Separate the cranberries (fresh or frozen) with 66 % in one bowl and 34 % in another bowl. This doesn’t have to be exact, just approximates are fine.
Step 3 – Prepare all the other ingredients
Measure the tapioca starch and then the sugar, and divide the sugar into 66 % and 34 % as well. Zest one orange and keep the zest aside. Also juice the orange (or use 100 % orange juice). If you’re using spices, measure and set them aside.

Step 4 – Cook the cranberries
Place the ⅔ portion of cranberries in a pot (image 1). Add the ⅔ portion of sugar, zest, orange juice, and spices into the same pot (images 2 – 3). Start cooking the mixture while stirring the cranberries.
The cranberries will soften as they heat up. Use a spoon to break down the cranberries to create a jammy mixture. Cook for about 8 – 10 minutes while frequently stirring to make a jammy cranberry sauce-like mixture (but not as thick as regular cranberry sauce) (image 4).
Transfer the mixture into a shallow, wide container (so it cools down faster) or a bowl (image 5), and set it aside.

Step 5 – Finish the filling
Whisk together the remaining sugar and tapioca starch (image 6).
Chop the remaining cranberries and place them in a large bowl. I just cut them in half (images 7 – 8).
Once the cooked cranberries have almost cooled down (a little warm is OK), add this to the chopped cranberries. Add the tapioca starch-sugar mixture and fold it together to combine (images 9 – 10).
You can use this filling immediately (image 11), OR place it in a sealable container and store it for later.

Step 6 – Prepare the pie dough and fill the pie
Preheat your oven to 400°F and keep an oven rack on the lowest rack of your oven. Also place a half sheet pan on the bottom rack to preheat as you assemble the pie.
Roll out a portion of pie dough and line a pie plate with the dough. Make sure to line it WITHOUT stretching the dough to prevent it from shrinking as it bakes. Leave an overhang and trim off excess dough (images 12 – 14).
Scrape in the cranberry pie filling (image 15) and cover with plastic wrap and keep it in the fridge until needed.

Roll out the second pie dough into a circle to fit the top of the pie. You can either make a full double crust pie, OR a lattice crust pie. This filling isn’t TOO juicy, because of the pectin in the cranberries, so you can use either a whole or a lattice top crust.
You can even opt for a crumble topping too.
I cut the dough into strips to create a lattice crust here (images 16 – 19).

Step 7 – Place the top crust
Press the top crust against the bottom crust to seal it together.
Then roll it under the excess dough overhang from the bottom crust to create the pie crust edge (image 20). Then crimp or flute the edge as well (image 21). Then let the pie rest in the fridge for the crust to harden – about 30 minutes.
If the dough becomes too soft or sticky before creating the fluted edge, I let the pie rest in the fridge to harden and then I flute the crust before baking the pie.

Step 8 – Bake the pie
Once the pie has chilled in the fridge, brush the surface with an egg wash and sprinkle the top with raw sugar (optional) (images 22 – 23).
Then bake the pie on top of the baking sheet in the preheated oven at 400°F for about 10 minutes, and then lower the heat to 350°F to bake for a further 50 – 70 minutes, until the crust is golden brown.

Step 9 – Cool and serve
After baking the pie, let it cool until it’s at least almost at room temperature. You can serve it while slightly warm – but the hotter the pie, the more runny the filling will be.
Serve the pie with whipped cream or ice cream on the side. It makes for an exceptional dessert on your Thanksgiving table too! 😊

Storage and make ahead tips
After baking
The cranberry pie will only last about 5 days in the fridge, as the crust will start to become stale and soggy.
However, you can easily make this pie ahead of time and freeze! Make sure it’s wrapped well with plastic wrap and foil. Since we use tapioca starch as the thickener here, the starch can withstand freezing and reheating without impacting the filling consistency (unlike cornstarch).
Allow the frozen cranberry pie to thaw out in the fridge overnight. Preheat the oven to 350°F / 180°C, and then heat the pie until heated through.
Before baking
Different parts of the pie can be stored in the fridge or freezer before baking.
You can make the filling and refrigerate it for about 2 days, or freeze it for about 1 month.
The pie dough will last in the fridge for about 4 – 5 days, but will last for 3 months in the freezer.
My best recipe tips
- If you’re using fresh cranberries, make sure the cranberries have a deep red color. The cranberries should be firm to the touch.
- Don’t overcook the cranberry filling. If you do, the filling will become too firm as it bakes.
- Adjust the spices to your taste. I prefer the tart, fruity cranberry flavor to be the undisputed star here, so I don’t add too much spice.
- Don’t decrease the amount of sugar in this recipe. Cranberries are very sour, and the sugar helps to balance this. But the sugar here doesn’t make the pie overly sweet either, and still perfectly highlights the tangy, tart cranberry flavor.
- Do not substitute the cranberries either. The sugar also helps with activating the natural pectin in cranberries.
- The pie dough needs to be cold while making it and also while handling the dough. This is because the butter pieces need to remain solid in the dough to create the flaky layers as the dough bakes.
- Bake the pie in a preheated oven, so that the crust has a chance to cook properly. Some ovens don’t regulate the temperature inside well until it’s preheated for a prolonged time (know it from experience!).
- Cooking the pie at a lower temperature for longer will help the pie bake more evenly – both the crust AND the filling.
- If the top crust browns too quickly, place a foil or silicone crust shield to protect the crust.

Simple recipe variations I love
The pie that I initially made that actually made me crave a cranberry pie was my sweet cherry pie (which I wanted to be more sour!). So cherry and cranberry make for a delicious combo. But you can also make other pie variations with cranberries too.
- Cherry and cranberry pie
- Apple cranberry pie
- Raspberry and cranberry pie
You can also change up the pie crust and the topping too.
- Crumble or streusel topping (like these apple pie bars or peach crumble bars)
- Graham cracker pie crust (for a buttery, flaky crust but with the nutty flavor of graham crackers!)

Recipe FAQs
My cranberry pie filling is runny
Pie filling becomes runny when there’s too much liquid for the thickener to effectively thicken.
However, with this recipe, the pectin and tapioca starch together thicken the filling really well. If the pie filling is still runny after baking, it’s usually because the ingredients were measured wrong, or any ingredient substitutions interfered with the final result.
My cranberry pie is too tart
I personally love the tartness of cranberries! This pie is meant to have a great balance between sweetness and tartness.
If you find the filling too tart, you can add a little extra sugar before baking. But adding too much sugar can make the filling too runny.
What to serve with this pie?
Whipped cream or ice cream are my favorite options. You can make easy chantilly cream or stabilized whipped cream to go with the pie. Or a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
Can I use store-bought pie crust to make this?
Yes! But you will need two crusts for the bottom, since this is made in a deep pie dish instead of a regular pie dish.
Stack the two pie crusts and then roll it out to make the circle bigger to fit a deep dish pan.
Recipe
Cranberry Pie
US based cup, teaspoon, tablespoon measurements. Weight measurements are recommended for accurate results whenever available.
Common Measurement ConversionsIngredients:
Cranberry pie filling (for a deep dish pie)
- 900 g cranberries 8 – 9 cups, fresh or frozen
- 400 g white sugar 2 cups
- ¼ tsp salt
- 1 tsp ground ginger
- ¾ tsp allspice
- 2 tsp vanilla extract
- 1 ½ tbsp orange zest
- 120 mL orange juice ½ cup
- 30 g tapioca starch about 3 ⅓ – 3 ¾ tbsp
For the pie
- 1 recipe all butter pie crust dough for two crusts
- 1 large egg for the egg wash
- 2 tbsp milk or cream (for the egg wash – optional)
- raw sugar to sprinkle on the top crust
Instructions:
Cranberry filling
- Wash and remove any soft, mushy cranberries (or any with soft / discolored spots). If you do remove any cranberries, make sure you still have the correct amount for the pie.
- Divide the cranberries into two portions. One portion will be ⅔ of the cranberries (about 600 g), and the other about ⅓ (about 300g). Doesn't have to be precise.
- Also divide the sugar into two portions. One portion about 300 g (1 ½ cups) and the remaining 100 g (½ cup).
- Place the larger portion of cranberries and the larger portion of sugar in a pot. Add the orange zest, orange juice, vanilla, salt, and spices. Mix to combine.600 g cranberries, 300 g white sugar, ¼ tsp salt, 1 tsp ground ginger, ¾ tsp allspice, 2 tsp vanilla extract, 1 ½ tbsp orange zest, 80 mL orange juice
- Cook over medium / medium high heat (at a temperature where you can control the cooking without burning the filling). Stir while cooking, and as the sugar melts and the cranberries soften, make sure to help break down the cranberries while stirring.
- Cook the mixture at a simmer, while stirring, for about 10 – 15 minutes, until the mixture starts to thicken. It should have a jammy consistency (but slightly runnier).
- Remove from the heat and transfer into a bowl and let it cool down.
- While the mixture cools, whisk together the sugar and tapioca starch in a separate bowl.100 g white sugar, 30 g tapioca starch
- Next, roughly chop (or halve) the remaining cranberries.300 g cranberries
- Once the cooked cranberries have cooled down considerably (slightly warm or at room temperature), add the halved cranberries and tapioca starch-sugar mixture. Also add the remaining orange juice (about 40 mL).40 mL orange juice
- Stir well to combine and to make sure the starch has dispersed well through the cranberries.
- The filling is now ready. Keep it covered until needed. Or transfer the mixture into an airtight container and keep it in the fridge if you're making this ahead of time.
Pie dough
- Make the pie dough at least a day ahead using my all butter pie dough recipe. You can also use store-bought pie crust, but you will need extra dough for the bottom crust as this recipe is for a deep pie dish.
- When the pie crust is ready, start preheating the oven.
- Preheat the oven to 400°F / 205°C. Place the oven rack on the bottom rack, along with a half sheet pan as you preheat the oven. For best results, have the oven at the preheated temperature for at least 45 minutes to allow the sheet pan to preheat properly as well.
Assembling the pie
- Roll out one portion of dough according to my double crust pie tutorial to line the pie plate. Make sure the dough is about 3 mm thick. Please take care not to stretch the dough to fit it in the pie dish.1 recipe all butter pie crust dough
- Scrape the prepared cranberry pie filling into the pie dish.
- Cover the pie dish and refrigerate until the top crust is ready.
- Roll out the second pie portion to fit the top of the pie. If you want to create a lattice crust, then cut the dough into strips.
- If you prefer a solid pie crust on top, then you can leave the pie crust whole.
- Create a lattice crust according to my lattice pie crust guide, and roll up the crust and flute the edge.
- OR, create a double pie crust according to my double pie crust guide, and roll up the crust and flute the edge. Make sure to create venting holes on the top crust as well to allow for steam evaporation.
- Refrigerate the pie for about 30 minutes to allow the crust to firm up and chill before baking. You can also put it in the freezer for about 15 – 20 minutes.
Baking
- When the pie is ready to be baked, whisk an egg yolk with some milk (or just a whole egg), to create an egg wash.1 large egg, 2 tbsp milk
- Remove the pie from the fridge and brush the top with the egg wash. Sprinkle the top with raw sugar (optional).raw sugar
- Place the pie on the preheated half sheet pan in the bottom rack of the oven.
- Bake the pie at 400°F / 205°C for about 10 minutes, then reduce the heat to 350°F / 180°C.
- Bake the pie for a further 50 – 60 minutes, or until the crust is golden brown on top.
- Remove the pie from the oven and let it cool down to room temperature before serving.
Recipe Notes
Nutrition Information:
“This website provides approximate nutrition information for convenience and as a courtesy only. Nutrition data is gathered primarily from the USDA Food Composition Database, whenever available, or otherwise other online calculators.”






















Leave a Reply